Placebo Is Not Good for You
Even if a placebo may appear to help at short term, one should always look further.
For a long list of ‘placebo side effects’, click here.
For an article by me on ResearchGate: [see RG: ”Placebos have many ‘side-effects’“]
Placebo is generally limited to relieving symptoms, as by the way also do most regular medications apart from – broadly speaking – antibiotics and chemotherapeutics.
That leaves to nature the job of curing disease.
OK. So at least, taking a placebo may relieve your symptoms. That seems positive. But is taking a placebo good for you? I seldom encounter this question. My answer is no.
I’m talking about placebo in a strict sense. I’m not talking about empathy, nor open suggestion – also not about an indigenous medicine as a vehicle of prescientific suggestion. definition, placebo in a strict sense involves something beyond truth. A patient is tricked into the placebo response. This should make alarm bells ring. Can an un-truth be good for health, in principle?
I frequently hear: “I don’t care about how it works. As long as it makes me feel better, then of course it’s OK to me.” Well – that makes me skeptical.
I don’t like an un-truth that seems to make people better.
I also frequently hear: “Well, since there is no active ingredient in the placebo, at least it has no side-effects.” At this point, I resolutely disagree. Of course, there are no side-effects stemming from a pure placebo’s active ingredient since there is no active ingredient. The placebo effect has another source: not physical but psychological. Purely logically, it’s there that one should also look for side-effects.
So the relevant question is: are there psychological side-effects?
Absolutely.
A placebo’s main message is that its power comes from the physical placebo and hence not from you. The truth is: the power of placebo definitely does come from you. Placebo thus is negative in two ways. First, it makes you psychologically dependent upon the placebo in the future. Second, it gives you an inner feeling of helplessness, which is generally regarded as one of the main causes for depression, burnout etc. Of course… with no deeper meaning involved, placebo-as-a-lie disrupts your natural flow of deeply self-healing power.
The consequences are huge.
Although it may feel otherwise, placebo is definitely not good for you.
Related Posts
The Dual Nature of Psychosomatic Illness
Psychosomatic illness appears when mental processes negatively influence physical health. Often misunderstood or oversimplified, these conditions highlight a fascinating frontier of scientific inquiry, bridging mental health and somatic medicine. Of course – and even though ‘psychosomatic’ often carries that connotation – the resulting physical symptoms are not ‘imagined’; they are genuine and often measurable. Changing Read the full article…
Lisa x Genetics
Recent advances in genetics have proven beyond any doubt that mental conditions of all sorts are highly DNA-influenced. This is very important for >Lisa<. Important in two ways: diagnostically and therapeutically. Our genes Much progress is being made in deciphering how heritability forms people’s mental landscapes. (*) Most interestingly, we increasingly see that ‘polygenic scores’ Read the full article…
Placebo and the Predictive Brain
The ‘brain as a predictive machine’ sheds an interesting light on the placebo effect. It shows that we are born with the wetware in place to experience the influence of placebo. Yet, the present-day may be the time to go beyond. Subconscious placebo Several explanations of the placebo effect have been put forward, such as Read the full article…