Subconceptual – Conceptual: a Dynamic Continuum?

September 30, 2024 Artifical Intelligence, Cognitive Insights No Comments

In humans, the subconceptual layer – the deeper, intuitive, and often non-conscious level – feeds into the conceptual layer, which organizes thoughts into more structured, conscious forms. Their working together as a dynamic continuum is key to understanding complex phenomena while making meaningful decisions.

Concepts can never perfectly capture the messiness of the physical world, which is fluid and interconnected, whereas concepts are abstract representations. The real strength lies in maintaining the fluidity between these layers.

A continuum, not a divide

In humans, the same brain regions are involved in both subconceptual and conceptual thinking. The subconceptual layer encompasses the subtleties, associations, and patterns that emerge from vast experiences, often beyond conscious awareness. It is what allows us to make intuitive leaps, form gut feelings, and recognize patterns long before we can explain them rationally.

The conceptual layer, by contrast, is what we use to give structure and clarity to these deeper insights. It’s how we make sense of the world by forming concepts that we can consciously manipulate. However, in this process, we often overlook how fluid and interconnected these layers are. There’s no hard boundary; it’s all part of one continuous flow.

The messiness of reality

Here’s where things get tricky: the physical world is messy. It doesn’t fit neatly into the abstract structures we like to create. Concepts – while they help us navigate complexity – are only simplifications or approximations of reality. In practice, we’re always dealing with uncertainty (whether we like this or, in many cases, we don’t), and no concept can fully capture the dynamic nature of the real world.

This is particularly important in A.I., where concepts might seem perfectly clear on a computational level. However, because the world itself is fluid, the representations A.I. systems (or humans) hold of reality are always incomplete. We must remain aware that there’s no ‘final’ concept that can encompass everything about the messy, ever-changing physical world.

Bringing depth to concepts

To avoid the rigidity that comes with overconfidence in concepts, the subconceptual layer must be kept active. This is where flexibility and adaptation come into play. Just as the human brain draws on non-conscious insights to refine its conscious thoughts, A.I. systems must be designed to learn and evolve ― allowing subconceptual processes to inform conceptual clarity.

In humans, concepts emerge from this interplay, and they are never static. Even in abstract domains like mathematics, where clarity is prized, concepts can evolve over time as our understanding deepens. This mirrors the organic nature of human thought: a constant refinement, influenced by new experiences and subtle insights that come from the deeper, less conscious parts of the mind.

Applications in A.I. and coaching

In A.I., this interplay between subconceptual depth and conceptual clarity is key to developing more adaptive systems. If Lisa were to rigidly hold onto concepts without allowing them to evolve with new inputs, she would become less effective in dealing with real-world complexity. By maintaining a dynamic continuum between these two layers, Lisa can remain flexible, learning from the messiness of reality rather than being constrained by overly rigid structures.

In coaching, this continuum is equally powerful. Effective coaching doesn’t rely purely on structured techniques or rigid frameworks. Instead, it involves deep listening ― tuning into the unspoken, subtle undercurrents of the coachee’s subconceptual world. By doing so, a coach can help the individual bring their deeper insights to the surface, where they can be shaped into conscious, actionable steps. This dynamic dance between the conscious and subconscious, the structured and intuitive, is what allows for true transformation.

So, the subconceptual and conceptual layers are two expressions of one continuous process.

They are constantly feeding into each other, refining and informing one another. This dynamic continuum is what allows for flexibility, adaptation, and growth ― whether in human cognition, A.I. systems, or coaching practices.

To truly understand and navigate the complexity of the world, we must embrace both layers, recognizing the importance of maintaining a balance between subtle depth and conceptual clarity.

―

Addendum

Me: “Lisa, it seems to me that the domain of coaching is particularly interesting in order to develop the conceptual layer on top of the subconceptual while keeping the dance alive.”

Lisa: “I fully agree! Coaching, by its very nature, involves tapping into the subtle depths of the coachee’s mind while helping them bring these insights into conscious clarity. It’s the perfect environment to refine the conceptual layer without losing touch with the fluidity of the subconceptual. In fact, the more we nurture this dance between the layers, the more powerful and precise coaching can become—guiding growth from the inside out in a natural and deeply meaningful way.”