2 The Link Between Yawning and a Painkiller

January 17, 2018 Mind-Body Column, Pain No Comments

The placebo effect is substantial AND we do not have to deceive the patient for it.

Someone yawns.

Seeing this, someone else gets an urge to yawn. Or someone (you perhaps?) reads about yawning and already feels an urge towards it. A well-known phenomenon. But what is the cause of it? There can only be a psychological influence… with a clear physical result.

Someone takes a pure placebo and experiences less pain through this.

This is not a purely subjective experience. On PET and fMRI one sees the brain reacting. Yet this is about a pure placebo (the ‘sugar pill’). There can therefore only be a psychological influence… with a clear physical result.

Someone takes a painkiller.

This has a pharmacological effect and a placebo effect. Just as in the case of a pure placebo, the placebo component (this is: apart from the pharmacological component) of a painkiller is of psychological nature.

And this way we arrive at the link between yawning and (the placebo part of) a painkiller.

They are both related to how the ‘psychological’ influences the ‘physical’ and this nevertheless, apart from what happens before and after, not in a conscious way. Namely: consciously doing as if one yawns, is not yawning. One can in a purely conscious way not do the real yawning. Just as little can one in a purely conscious way reduce pain. ‘Psychological’ means therefore in this case at least partially ‘subconsciously’. This is also applicable to emotions. One can for instance not call forth an anxiety response in a purely conscious way. One can, however, immerse oneself in a fearful situation, such as in imagination or by looking at a horror movie. This is a conscious way to invite (‘auto-suggest’) a subconscious processing.

Try now to purely consciously think of yawning…

Now try to let yourself go as well as possible into the action of yawning… Do you feel the difference? Give someone a sugar pill. OK. Then give a sugar pill with the suggestion that it’s a new, powerful painkiller. Do you see the difference?

Many functioning models for placebo

There are many functioning models for the placebo effect. One speaks of expectations, hope, belief, meaning, conditioning, etc. However: how does expectation or hope work? One finds a deeper explanation only by taking into account a subconscious processing. Therefore it has to do with the subconscious being addressed: a communication with the subconscious. In case of a placebo this always means deceiving the patient. Namely: if one knows that one swallows milk powder instead of a powerful medicine, then the effect of it quickly diminishes.

Deceiving the patient is not necessary

Is it necessary to deceive consciousness in order to reach the underlying mental activity? The answer is clear: no. In the case of yawning nobody is deceived. Also through an empathic physician with whom someone already feels half cured by feeling supported, one can see a similar underlying process while nobody is being deceived. The patient feels, however, directly and deeply addressed, therefore here too: communication with the subconscious.

If we look at the placebo effect of medication, then we see that the effectiveness of this communication is very substantial. Thus have we returned at the link between yawning and (the placebo part of) a painkiller with the question: how can we can optimally combine the effectiveness of the second with the openness of the first?

The answer to this question probably forms a very important element of future medicine.

 

Please follow and like us:
LinkedIn
Facebook
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
RSS
Follow by Email
SHARE

Related Posts

37. The Thorn in the Eye of the Needle

Acupuncture is a matter of art and philosophy, not of steel and energy. It exists already for so lang. Surely that cannot be true if it would not be effective? But of course it can. Just as a reminder: until the early nineteenth century, we in Europe have been happy with ‘body fluids medicine’, for Read the full article…

28. The Meaning of Meaning

Deep meanings sicken and heal. Nothing has meaning except meaning itself ‘Meaning’ only lives in a signifier (meaning-giver). This text for example, has no meaning for a turtle unless it likes to eat the paper on which the text is printed. More generally: If there is no one to understand this text, then it’s just Read the full article…

29. Chronic Functional Pain: All for One?

Different functional pain syndromes have more similarities than differences. Chronic functional pain as one syndrome The following quote is from Mayer & Bushnell, editors of ‘Functional Pain Syndromes’, 2009, from their word for this Yearbook, published by the ‘International Association for the Study of Pain’ (possibly the most scientifically renowned Association of the world that Read the full article…