The Art of Feedback
In feedback, you find ‘to feed’ = ‘to give food.’ Nutrition is necessary to grow. The purpose of feedback is GROWTH. Otherwise, it’s pointless.
Letting it muddle through turns small fires into more significant fires.
Thus, if something is not optimal, you have a responsibility to point this out, together with:
- giving suggestions for improvement
- providing the necessary to implement this improvement
- deciding this together
- ensuring openness.
It’s always an emotional affair.
Giving attention to the concerned person is also always important (not just in an email). If this attention is poorly given, one risks in response:
- a retreat
- shifting blame to others
- returning emotional criticism
- low motivation, low will to change
- silent resistance and ‘sabotage’ (consciously or unconsciously).
Tips for giving feedback.
ESPECIALLY: keep in mind the meaning level. At this level, there is often a strong sensitivity.
Show that you want to understand the other as well as possible. Also, really make an effort to come to this understanding.
My few tips:
- Show that you want to understand the other as well as possible. Also, make an effort to come to this understanding.
- Give a lot of positive feedback. This is very motivating. People often learn a lot from this.
- Describe only changeable behavior. So, no criticism of what someone is.
- Clearly describe a concrete behavior that you have seen or heard yourself. Avoid words like ‘always’ and ‘never.’ Don’t just rely on the knowledge of others.
- Use a spacious I-message. For instance: “I’d like it to be different.”
- Indicate the effect that some behavior has on you. Feel free to involve your emotions. Show the consequences of the behavior for you. Let the other empathize with your feelings.
- Let your conversation partner respond. Allow time for this. Also, guide that response to some depth if possible.
- Avoid accusations. You have no use for the anger of others. Provide precise and neutral wording that avoids any accusatory interpretation if possible.
- Make sure you know what you want to achieve. Well, subtlety. No vagueness.
- Explore solutions or backgrounds together. Create a sense of co-responsibility.
- Appreciate the silence in which the other person can come to their own ‘feedback.’ The feedback that comes from the person himself is always the most ‘growing.’
I hope this brings you somewhere.
Self-learning
Of course, this is a perfect situation to learn from feedback about how to give feedback. It’s a self-perpetuating pattern.
I hope that, eventually, this brings you very far.
Enjoy the ride!
Related Posts
Between Depersonalizations
A person is a dynamically evolving agent (volitional subject) with enough stability to feel like a persistent entity and enough flexibility to stay alive and thrive in changing circumstances, to ‘remain the same by changing.’ Thus, a person – living dynamic system – can depersonalize in two directions: toward too much or too little flexibility. Read the full article…
The Modern Subconscious
“Consciousness is a much smaller part of our mental life than we are conscious of, because we cannot be conscious of what we are not conscious of. How simple is that to say; how difficult to appreciate!” (J. Jaynes 1976) From light waves to consciousness When looking at the world, we are consciously aware of Read the full article…
Never Change a Habit
Instead, let the habit change you. We’ve been told that to improve our lives, we need to break bad habits and form good ones. The idea seems simple — identify a habit, replace it with a better one, and repeat until it sticks. But anyone who has tried to forcefully change a habit knows how Read the full article…