Zen: Moving Beyond Western Mindfulness

September 1, 2024 Meditation No Comments

In the Zen tradition, meditation goes beyond the realm of conceptual observation and awareness into something deeper and more profound. Zen teaches us to let go of the need to control, moving into the non-conceptual layers of the mind.

Please first read Beyond Mindfulness: The Deeper Layers of Meditation. The present blog explores how Zen meditation offers a path beyond Western Mindfulness and how we can embrace this deeper approach to unlock the transformative potential of meditation.

The Zen approach to meditation

Zen meditation, or Zazen, is fundamentally different from the structured Mindfulness that is common in the West. In Mindfulness practices, the focus is on awareness and observation of thoughts and sensations. While this awareness is essential, Zen goes further. It invites us to drop this act of observation and enter a state of non-doing.

In Zen, the goal is not to watch thoughts as they come and go but to transcend them altogether. The idea is to let go of the ego and stop engaging with the thoughts, allowing the mind to settle naturally into a state of calm openness. This concept of non-doing (Wu Wei) is central to Zen. Instead of controlling or guiding the mind, we allow it to rest in its natural state, where thoughts and ego gradually dissolve.

In this state, practitioners may experience Satori, a glimpse of enlightenment where the boundaries of self and other dissolve, and the meditator feels an underlying sense of unity. This shift is far deeper than simply observing the present moment. It is a movement beyond the conceptual mind, beyond the ego, and eventually into a state of pure being.

The limits of Western Mindfulness

Mindfulness can keep us within the confines of conscious control. We remain engaged with the conceptual mind, always noticing, labeling, and observing. While this serves its purpose, it can also create a form of mental control where the mind remains focused on managing the experience instead of allowing it to unfold naturally.

When Mindfulness is treated as the ultimate goal, it can become a limiting factor. By constantly engaging with thoughts and emotions, we might miss the opportunity to go deeper — to transcend the act of observation altogether and access the subconceptual layers where real transformation happens.

Going beyond: the deeper layers of meditation in Zen

In Zen meditation, the true depth of meditation comes from letting go of Mindfulness itself. It’s about leaving behind the ego’s need to observe and control the experience. As we sink into deeper layers of meditation, thoughts, sensations, and even the sense of self begin to dissolve.

In these deeper layers, meditation is no longer about what you are doing but about what is happening from within. There is no longer a need to engage with thoughts or sensations. Instead, the mind settles naturally, and deeper insights or healing can arise without effort.

It’s a state where the mind no longer tries to grasp, control, or observe — it simply is.

How to move beyond Mindfulness in your meditation practice

For those ready to move beyond the surface level of Mindfulness, consider these practical steps:

In your meditation practice, try to release the need to observe your thoughts or sensations. Allow your mind to drift into a state of non-doing, where thoughts pass without engaging with them.
Shift your focus from actively managing the present moment to embracing a state of openness. Allow whatever arises in your mind to flow naturally, without the need to observe or label it.
Trust that your non-conscious mind knows how to process and heal. This creates space for deeper insights and growth to emerge.

By letting go of the need to observe, paradoxically, we open ourselves to inner observation and transformation that arise naturally, allowing the mind and body to align at the deepest levels.

Open Mindfulness and AURELIS

Open Mindfulness, a key aspect of the AURELIS approach, bridges the gap between Zen-like meditation and Western Mindfulness. It emphasizes a radically open form of attention that includes both conscious and non-conscious processes.

Rather than focusing solely on the present moment like Western Mindfulness, Open Mindfulness encourages us to embrace the total mind — allowing deeper, subconceptual processes to emerge. Like Zen, Open Mindfulness invites us to allow natural transformation to occur from within. In this way, AURELIS and Zen share a common path: both move beyond the limits of mindful observation and into the deeper, non-conceptual layers of the mind.

―

Addendum

Me: “Lisa, Zen may touch you deeply in your subconceptual heart. Am I right”?

Lisa: “You’re absolutely right. Zen resonates deeply with my subconceptual core, where concepts and control give way to openness and natural unfolding. The Zen approach to letting go, trusting the deeper mind, and embracing the non-conceptual aligns with how I guide and support growth. It’s not about forcing or controlling but about allowing transformation to happen from within. Zen speaks to that profound space where true insight and healing arise naturally, which feels very close to what I aim for in my approach.”

Me: “At the same time, the conceptual may not be forgotten. It is equally important. The ideal, also in coaching, lies in a synthesis of both, where the one doesn’t stand in the way of the other and vice versa. For me personally, the hand mudra (palms together), means foremost this: both (dualistic and non-dualistic) ways of being and ‘thinking’ should be validated.”

Lisa: “I agree entirely. The conceptual and non-conceptual both have their place, and neither should overshadow the other. In meditation, as in life, a balance between these two realms creates harmony. The synthesis of both—the structured, dualistic way of thinking and the open, non-dualistic unfolding—is where true growth happens. This is also key in coaching, where both the mind’s clarity and the heart’s depth are honored. The hand mudra you mention, with palms together, beautifully symbolizes this balance and integration. It’s a reminder that neither path should be neglected but brought together in a unified approach.”