The Disease and the Reality

January 1, 2020 Health & Healing No Comments

Disease differentiates the healthy from the diseased. Reality is much fuzzier.

Continua

In another blog text, I described diseases as – at least in many cases – continua rather than binary entities. [see: “A Disease is a Continuum, Not an Entity“] There is also a continuum from healthy to ‘diseased.’ I also wrote about disease as multidimensional. This text goes further on the latter.

Perspectives A and B, according to the degree of dispersion:

Two perspectives

Dispersed diseases

Autism, for instance, is not this disease that one can have or have-not. ‘Autism spectrum disorder’ is a step in a more realistic direction. Still.

In textbooks like DSM-V, diseases are distinct entities. Each disease is like some meteor that has been found in the universe. One can send a probe that lands on the meteor to investigate it and learn more about its characteristics. It looks like image A.

In reality, such – conceptual – characteristics of autism (or schizophrenia, or depression) are dispersed over the population. One can find some characteristics in this person here, some there, yet somewhere else is someone with a solitary outspoken characteristic, and so on. It looks like image B.

Note that in perspective B, there is a crowding of characteristics in a particular region. The difference between A and B also lies on a continuum.

Dispersed sleep

‘Normal’ conditions also have this characteristic to some degree. Sleep, for instance, is usually a nicely delineated on-off phenomenon. However, there are many conditions in which one or more of its characteristics appear without the others — for instance, sleepwalking, microsleeps, hypnogogic hallucinations, and narcolepsy.

One can lie awake for brief periods at night yet have the impression of lying awake all night, being tired in the morning. On the other side, one can lie awake and deeply rest, being well relaxed and fit in the morning.

Consequences

Looking for causality in both perspectives is very different. In perspective-A, the hunt is for one or more distinct causes, like a nail in a flat tire. Perspective-B more readily lends itself to a much broader view upon causality: as a conglomerate of factors that are as dispersed as the ‘disease’ itself. Perspective-B is closer to thinking in terms of complexity: several causes reinforcing each other on a path towards symptoms.

Management is also different. In perspective-B, the search for ‘the pill’ is, to say the least, less important than the search for how one can dynamically support someone towards self-healing. This is growth, as well as a diminishment of suffering.

Fitting to the goal of Compassion. [see: “Two-Sided Compassion“]

The promise

Proper management holds the promise to guide the person towards health from a broad perspective. Some ‘symptoms’ may rather be positive assets. The ‘diseased person’ is and always has been a healthy – although somewhat atypical – element of a society that values diversity.

People are typically atypical.

And that is perfectly OK.

Eventually, to a considerable degree, being healthy is a choice. [see: “What is Health?“]

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Growth versus Repair in Therapy

The confusion between growth and repair is rampant in therapy of all sorts. Generally, there is too much emphasis on repair. Medicine fundamentally wants to repair In the wake of the physical model, this is logical. For instance, if your car breaks down, please don’t wait until it grows towards a solution. Likewise, if you Read the full article…

Chronic Muscle Tensions

Chronic muscle tensions are a widespread issue impacting many people. They often result from a complex interplay of physical and psychological factors. Addressing them comprehensively requires consideration of both somatic and psychosomatic elements. 12 key highlights Chronic muscle tensions arise from a combination of physical and psychological factors, requiring a holistic approach to address them. Read the full article…

The Healing of Respect Wounds

Respect wounds rarely come with loud complaints or visible scars. They move quietly, shaping how people see themselves, how they interact, how they hesitate. These wounds are easy to overlook. But they are deep, and they matter. Healing them begins not with fixing, but with seeing what was never seen before. Someone with a respect Read the full article…

Translate »