73. The revenge of the tonsils

January 29, 2018 Health & Healing, Sticky Thoughts No Comments

Things may appear rational, but that’s no guarantee that they are. Sometimes, I mean most of the time, we are not aware of this as much as we should. The result is that we live in a very irrational world and are not even aware of it. The house of Homo Sapiens is a house of ‘knowing’, but its foundations are shaky, its cellars dark, its walls rather made of cardboard than of bricks. Mr. and Mrs. S. do not want to see this, but somewhere deep inside they feel it. This is scary to them and makes them especially vulnerable to any salesman coming by with an assortment of pseudorationality.

◊◊◊

What on earth has this to do with tonsils?

◊◊◊

During the fifth year of medical school, we were ‘invited’ to attend in small groups the daily practices of a number of specialists. I remember now a day at the cabinet of an otorhinolaryngologist. That is medicalish for a physician who is keen on ears, noses and throats. This specific old specimen was especially keen on what throats have to offer, mostly the tonsils. So my group of students attended the removal of the tonsils from some children. A bit of local anesthesia. Child in chair. Then with an instrument that looked like someone was going to grab your tonsils, he grabbed the tonsils of the poor lad, gave basically a simple twist of faith and with a cry… no, I’m exaggerating… with a smile of victory he showed his precious prize. Number, I guess, 20.000 of a very prolific career. Makes one swallow…

◊◊◊

What on earth has this to do with being rational or not?

◊◊◊

It happened that shortly before that day at the oto-man’s, we had a course about this. A gentle professor explained to us that for many years, tonsils had been removed from children about a 100 times too often. The rationality had been that infected tonsils were ‘bad things’. Well, they look very unsavory indeed. Not exactly what you would stick into your mouth if they weren’t there already…

◊◊◊

Sorry for the nauseating picture. The truth isn’t very nice either.

◊◊◊

By the way, if you are my age or older, where are your tonsils now?

◊◊◊

What had been forgotten, is that if the body reacts this way to an infection, it may have its reasons to do so. In this case, of course, it has. Tonsils are a defense mechanism against infections. Their place is in the mouth, not in a medical garbage collector, unless they really very much make a mess of it and are beyond repair. The history of tonsil removals is a history of preferring pseudorationality over the wisdom of nature. If only it looks rational, people are quick in not thinking further. In the case of the tonsils for instance, they easily could have and they should have.

◊◊◊

People make mistakes. They mis-take the degree of rationality in everything that seems rational at first sight. The tonsils are but one small example of very many. We should strive for much more rationality. If you look at this world, you see that it’s extremely urgent. There is no time to be coy or lazy about this.

◊◊◊

The tonsils and all other ‘garbage’ are already taking revenge.

◊◊◊

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Are RCTs valid in Psychotherapy?

Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) are a lab-based study design in which one tries to minimize confounding factors by comparing groups that are as similar as possible except for the property or properties under study. Getting physical These trials are meant to be as close as possible to studies in the field of physics. In these, Read the full article…

Fundamental Reality in Psychology

On top of solid ground, psychology and psychotherapy can thrive as never before. In natural evolution, one can discern a schematic progression (Artificial Life may be different) Matter As we know, matter is chaotic, bent on entropy. One can see this as the absence of purpose. Without purpose, all motion in matter is a happening. Read the full article…

Are Mental Problems Social Problems?

Psycho-social. There is always an interplay. Looking in-depth, even more so. No issue will be solved by putting one against the other. Meanwhile, individuals need guidance and support as total persons, not as wheels in some clockwork. ‘Mental problems’ For the sake of this text, I categorize as such all issues regarded as psychological or Read the full article…

Translate »