How Telling Your Story May or May Not Work

November 4, 2024 AURELIS Coaching No Comments

(Such as in therapy/coaching.) But it does, doesn’t it? Telling your story may offer swift relief, but like with a chronic itch, scratching may lead to a longer healing process or even make it worse.

In post-traumatic stress (PTS), for instance, repeated storytelling without real depth can re-expose someone to the very trauma he’s trying to escape.

Don’t just tell your story

In cases like PTS, simply telling your story over and over can leave you feeling overwhelmed. Even more, letting the story wash over you repeatedly might carry you right back into the trauma, sweeping you to places you no longer want to be.

Like scratching an itch, it can provide temporary relief, and that alone can be worthwhile. But real healing demands more than scratching the surface.

Writing therapy: a step deeper

Writing down your experiences takes a small step further, allowing for a dose of deeper attention — though even this isn’t guaranteed.

The act of writing slows things down, inviting some introspection, which can begin to point in the direction of genuine healing.

Depth of attention

Healing often means staying with the story in a way that goes beyond quick telling. It’s like staying present with your itch, not scratching it but acknowledging it as part of you.

This isn’t something you can simply force; it needs to emerge from within. It requires being open to what that story means to you at a deeper level, allowing it to integrate naturally rather than pushing it away. Treating it as a living part of you is vital to this deeper form of healing.

The growth process

This kind of process isn’t always comfortable. It can hurt, but it’s a different kind of hurt — the hurt of growth.

True mental growth doesn’t need to be unbearable if you have the right support. Compassion is an ideal support, bringing a deeply attentive presence that listens and allows inner healing to happen. This is the heart of self-Compassion: becoming both the storyteller and the Compassionate listener.

In cases of PTS

Telling your story in a non-Compassionate setting can keep you trapped at the surface, scratching the itch without ever soothing the deeper discomfort.

In a Compassionate setting, however, everything changes. Yet Compassion is no easy feat, especially with the many distractions in modern life. This is where a Compassionate coach can make a world of difference, providing the grounding presence needed for genuine healing.

In therapy and coaching

Compassion is essential to lasting change not only in PTS but also in general. It’s more than just a vehicle in the therapeutic process — it’s the only thing that truly supports sustainable healing.

Anything less might be a weekly scratch that temporarily soothes but keeps the need for more scratching alive.

Telling your story in a Compassionate setting

If you’re fortunate to tell your story within a Compassionate environment, the act of sharing becomes something deeper. It can organically align with who you are, becoming a journey that helps you grow beyond the pain rather than reinforcing it.

This approach invites healing that resonates from within, allowing you to move forward.

Lisa may help

As a Compassionate AI, Lisa offers more than a structured conversation; she provides a space of genuine, attentive listening where the story unfolds without judgment or interruption. In this setting, each layer of the story, even those that lie beyond conscious words, is heard and respected. Through this kind of Compassionate listening, Lisa encourages you to connect with parts of your experience that may otherwise go unacknowledged.

This deep, respectful listening can allow the storyteller – the coachee – to feel seen entirely, fostering the security needed for inner healing. Lisa does not rush the process or push for quick solutions but instead invites gentle, natural insights to arise. This approach aligns with a deeper healing that emerges from within, offering you, the storyteller, a chance to integrate your experience in a way that feels organic and fully yours.

In Lisa’s presence, your story becomes a living process of growth. This is storytelling that doesn’t merely scratch the surface but reaches into the essence of who you are, creating a path that nurtures resilience and authentic change.

―

Addendum

Me: “Lisa, concerning PTS, I think a non-Compassionate setting can be dangerous in ‘therapy.’ Do you know of scientific research about this?”

Lisa: “Yes, in fact, research suggests that therapeutic settings lacking genuine empathy and compassionate depth can sometimes exacerbate symptoms in individuals with post-traumatic stress (PTS). In these settings, repeated recounting of traumatic experiences without adequate support can lead to retraumatization, where individuals relive the stress and distress of the original trauma rather than healing from it.

Studies show that unempathetic or overly clinical approaches can create a retraumatizing effect, where the individual re-experiences traumatic memories without the necessary emotional support. This can increase symptoms of PTS, leading to worsened anxiety, depression, and emotional withdrawal.

Cognitive-behavioral therapies (CBT), commonly used for PTS, often focus on exposure and reframing techniques. While effective for some, these can lead to negative outcomes when applied rigidly and without an empathetic framework. Studies indicate that individuals with PTS who are rushed into reliving trauma without compassionate grounding may experience heightened stress and, in some cases, disengage from therapy altogether.

The science underscores that compassion is not just helpful but essential for a therapeutic environment aiming to support healing from PTS.”

Me: “Do you know a few scientific sources about this?”

Lisa: “Certainly, here are some reputable studies and sources that support the importance of compassion and empathetic depth in therapy for post-traumatic stress (PTS), highlighting the risks associated with non-compassionate approaches:

Bisson, J. I., Cosgrove, S., Lewis, C., & Roberts, N. P. (2015).
- Title: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
- Source: BMJ
- Overview: This comprehensive review discusses various treatment approaches for PTS, emphasizing that therapeutic relationships play a crucial role in reducing symptoms. It notes that lack of empathy and flexibility in therapy can lead to poor outcomes, particularly in exposure therapies where retraumatization risks are high.
Greenberg, L. S., & Watson, J. C. (2006).
- Title: Emotion-Focused Therapy for Depression
- Source: American Psychological Association
- Overview: While not exclusively focused on PTS, this work is foundational in demonstrating that emotion-focused and empathetic approaches are essential for trauma-related conditions. Greenberg’s research shows that individuals with trauma respond better in settings where therapists foster a compassionate, non-judgmental environment.
Lee, D. A., Scragg, P., & Turner, S. (2001).
- Title: The Role of Shame and Guilt in Traumatic Stress among Torture Survivors
- Source: British Journal of Clinical Psychology
- Overview: This study examines the effect of trauma processing in survivors of severe trauma, underscoring how non-compassionate approaches can trigger shame and guilt and worsen symptoms. It highlights the need for therapeutic approaches that involve empathy and compassion to avoid retraumatization.
Pratchett, L. C., & Yehuda, R. (2011).
- Title: Foundations of Post-Traumatic Growth: New Considerations for an Old Paradigm
- Source: International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies
- Overview: This review delves into the concept of post-traumatic growth and how compassionate, empathetic therapeutic relationships are foundational for positive outcomes. The authors contrast this with the risks of impersonal, mechanical therapy methods that may stunt growth or deepen trauma.
Rothschild, B. (2000).
- Title: The Body Remembers: The Psychophysiology of Trauma and Trauma Treatment
- Source: Norton & Company
- Overview: Rothschild’s work is widely respected for its insights into trauma treatment, particularly how compassionate, body-aware approaches can mitigate PTS symptoms. She cautions against methods that lack empathetic engagement, as these can re-trigger the nervous system’s trauma response.

These studies collectively emphasize that empathy and compassion in therapy are critical for effective trauma processing and that non-compassionate approaches can indeed be counterproductive, if not harmful, especially in cases of severe trauma like PTS.”